7 Polk County restaurants that stand the test of time – and taste

Polk County’s culinary identity is built on deep roots, with many institutions serving the community for over 50 years. From lakeside fish shacks to legendary downtown diners, here are seven restaurants that have truly stood the test of time.

---

1. Reececliff Family Diner (Lakeland)

Est. 1934 As the oldest restaurant in Polk County, Reececliff is a living monument to the American diner. Originally opened as “The Ducky Wucky,” it has remained a South Florida Avenue staple for over 90 years.

• The Vibe: Classic, unpretentious Southern hospitality with wood booths and nostalgic decor.
• The Must-Order: Their world-famous fruit pies. The same pie expert baked for them for nearly 60 years, and the tradition of scratch-made crusts continues today.

2. Peebles Bar-B-Q (Auburndale)

Est. 1947 Tucked away in what was once a simple chicken shack, Peebles is the oldest BBQ joint in the county. It’s a “pilgrimage” spot for anyone who values the low-and-slow tradition over modern frills.

• The Vibe: Rustic and authentic. You’ll often find a line of locals trailing out the door, drawn in by the smell of the hickory wood smoke.
• The Must-Order: The sliced pork sandwich or a slab of ribs, served with their signature pit-cooked sides.

3. Old Man Frank’s (Winter Haven)

Est. 1954 Perched on the shores of Lake Howard, Old Man Frank’s has survived hurricanes and decades of change while keeping its “lakeside sunset” spirit alive.

• The Vibe: A quintessential Florida “dive” atmosphere where the dress code is casual and the views are premier.
• The Must-Order: Oysters on the half shell or the fresh catch of the day, enjoyed on the deck during happy hour.

4. Fat Jack’s Deli & Pub (Lakeland)

Est. 1963 A cornerstone of the Dixieland neighborhood, Fat Jack’s has been the go-to breakfast and lunch spot for generations of Lakelanders. It’s the kind of place where the staff knows the regulars by name.

• The Vibe: A bustling, friendly deli where the coffee is always refilled and the grill never stops.
• The Must-Order: A short stack of pancakes or their classic Reuben sandwich.

5. Jimbo’s Pit Bar B-Q (Lakeland)

Est. 1964 Located on Memorial Boulevard, Jimbo’s has been a family-run affair for over 60 years. They famously claim to be the “best eatin’ in town,” and their longevity suggests many locals agree.

• The Vibe: A vintage walk-up and dine-in spot that feels frozen in the best part of the 1960s.
• The Must-Order: The barbecue plate with a thick slice of their homemade pie for dessert.

6. Mister Fish (Lakeland)

Est. 1968 For over 50 years, Mister Fish has proven that you don’t need a fancy dining room to be a local legend. This walk-up eatery near Lake Morton is a masterclass in consistency.

• The Vibe: No-frills, quick-service seafood that has maintained its quality since the day it opened.
• The Must-Order: The fried fish sandwich basket—it’s the gold standard for many Lakeland residents.

7. Harry’s Old Place (Winter Haven)

Est. 1992. While the “youngest” on this list, Harry’s Old Place, earned its “timeless” status by focusing on the “Real Florida” experience. It’s a Winter Haven legend for fresh-from-the-dock seafood.

• The Vibe: Casual, wood-heavy interior that feels like a cozy fishing lodge.
• The Must-Order: Check the chalkboard specials for the freshest seasonal fish, often prepared with their signature “Harry’s Style” toppings.